Super Sam

Category: DC Verse Television > SuperGirl
Dragon prints: 2455
Disclaimer: I do not own Supergirl or anything to do with DC. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

Samantha Arias had never been more nervous in her entire life. It was kind of a ridiculous feeling to have, considering what she had been through, which was a lot of stressful things, even before being taken over by her evil alter ego, but the fact remains this was her first date in years, and her first one ever with someone she actually liked. Hell, she had been nervous enough when she been talked into going on blind dates, or the 'hangout sessions' of her youth, but this was so much worse. Also her first official date with another woman, and she worried that she was going to freak out and make a fool out of herself, and ruin whatever Alex had planned. And she was stressed out because she didn't know what that was. And she had nothing to wear! And Alex was going to be here any minute! Oh God, what was she going to do?

"Oh for God sakes Mom, just pick something." Ruby groaned with frustration, and then when she saw the expression on her mother's face she softened her tone, and added, "Hey, hey, hey, it's going to be okay. Alex is going to love what you wear, no matter what, and you guys are going to have a great evening, okay?"

"You don't know that." Sam grumbled softly.

"Of course I do." Ruby countered, quickly listing off, "You could wear a paper bag, and Alex would still love it. And have you seen you guys together? You're going to never run out of things to say to each other. And as for everyone else, who cares what they think? Alex makes you happy, you know that. And you deserve happiness. And if some people can't see that, that's their problem. And as for saying or doing the wrong thing, you would never do that, but if you somehow do, I'm sure Alex will understand, and do whatever she can to make you feel comfortable, and give you a second chance, if you need it. But I don't think you will, because you're awesome Mom, and so is Alex. You two deserve each other."

"Thanks honey." Sam smiled after a brief pause, "You're a good kid."

"I know." Ruby beamed proudly.

Of course, Ruby wasn't psychic, Sam had just spent the last few hours burdening her child with her deepest insecurities, something normally she was good at hiding from Ruby, but that was just what Alex Danvers did to her. Which bizarrely, was part of the other woman's charm. After all, nobody else made Sam this nervous, and excited. So even though she obsessed over what to wear and what to say. There was no way she was missing out on this night. And Ruby was right. Hopefully. Oh God, Sam had never hoped her child was right about something more than this. Especially when she found herself opening the door pretty much the second the doorbell rang, revealing Alex Danvers looking effortlessly stunning.

"Wow." Sam softly murmured.

"I think that's my line." Alex smirked.

"Smooth." Sam quipped, trying to sound mocking, even though she kinda meant it.

"I try." Alex grinned, before indicating, "Shall we?"

"Sure." Sam nodded, shutting and locking the door behind her, and then awkwardly asking on the way to Alex's car, "So... what did you have in mind for, you know?"

"You know?" Alex raised an eyebrow teasingly.

Sam gave her a look, and then simply said dryly, "Our date. Sorry, this is new to me. And not just because you're a girl. Like I said-"

"It's okay, I was just teasing. I really shouldn't have, I'm sorry." Alex quickly apologized.

"It's okay." Sam reassured, before gently pushing, "So where are we going for our first official date?"

"It's a surprise." Alex said dismissively.

"Okay." Sam said, "I love surprises."


"I hate surprises." Sam grumbled a short time later.

There was a brief pause, then Alex confessed, "You know, I spent hours deciding where to take you. But-"

"You did?" Sam interrupted, feeling touched.

"Of course. You mean a lot to me." Alex promised, "And even if we were strangers, anyone who doesn't put the time into thinking how to please you, isn't worthy of you."

"Sap." Sam blushed a little, before remembering where they were, and then looking away and grumbling, "So, you were explaining why you're taking the alien to an alien bar?"

"Because you're not comfortable with the fact you're an alien." Alex said softly, "I know you want just to separate yourself from Reign, and label her as the alien, but it's just not that simple. And I can't stand the idea that you would hate yourself for who you are. You're not Reign, but you are Kryptonian. No matter what happened to you. I just want you to be proud of that."

"And you thought the best way was to force this on me?" Sam said bitterly, still not looking at Alex.

"I thought it would be so distracting, you wouldn't really think about where you are." Alex explained softly, "I thought that it could be a first step into accepting your heritage. To be around other... refugees like you. Some of which have to hide who they are in public. And others who don't have that luxury. Who can't forget what they are, no matter how hard they try? Or we can go to one of the other half a dozen bars in this area. Or to dinner and a movie, or I can even just take you home, if I've completely ruined the mood. I just... I just wanted this to be special, and for there to be no pressure, at least not romantically. And honestly, this is my favourite place. Where I'm most comfortable. And I wanted you to see it, and hated you haven't been back since, you know..."

There was a long pause, and then Sam finally turned to Alex and grumbled, "So, just to recap, you're risking our chance to be together, to try and make me feel better about myself?"

"I wouldn't put it like that, but... yeah, I guess?" Alex admitted with a soft smile.

"Huh..." Sam hummed, before reluctantly admitting, "You're a good friend, you know that right?"

"I'd like to think so." Alex smiled softly, before quickly adding, "Although, I'm hoping I haven't just friend-zoned myself."

"You're good." Sam reassured.

There was then a brief pause, and then Alex gently pushed, "So, what do you want to do?"

"Well..." Sam bit her lip thoughtfully for a few long seconds, and then sighed as she admitted, "I think you're right. Sooner or later I'm going to have to face this, and I'd rather do it while I was distracted. And, and while I have someone I trust by my side."

"You will." Alex promised, "Supergirl and J'ohn swore to me that they had things handled tonight, so I'll be there every step of the way. I promise."

"I believe you. If I didn't, well..." Sam trailed off, as she and Alex got out of the car and started walking in the direction of the bar. Sam then held out her hand and then awkwardly asked, "Can we..."

"Sure." Alex replied quickly, saving Sam from having to say it.

Which was namely of course holding hands, and it was ridiculous and embarrassing that Sam couldn't seem to say that. It was bad enough that she was hesitant to call this initially a 'date', and two women could get away with holding hands in public without it necessarily being gay. Although she had been taken off-guard, and Alex Danvers had the tendency to make her nervous. But still, Sam was embarrassed of that, and the effect that such a small thing had over her body. Because it was embarrassing to feel such a connection, just from holding someone's hand, which just proves how pathetically touch starved she was. Luckily from the look that Alex gave her she didn't seem to be alone in these overwhelming feelings.

Then they were at the door of the bar, and Sam actually needed to take a calming breath, and paused for a second, before stepping inside. Alex didn't say anything, but just her presents there was a big help. Which continued to be the case as they walked through the bar, lined up, got a couple of drinks, and sat down at a booth. Which was pretty standard stuff, except they were surrounded by aliens of all shapes and sizes. Given she was one of them it probably should've made Sam feel comfortable, but she had never felt more uncomfortable in her own skin, and guilty for the things she had done as Reign. Yes, yes, that wasn't her, but in moments like this she wasn't so sure that there was a difference. Especially now she remembered everything this body had done.

"Are you okay?" Alex asked softly, after a few long seconds, and then gently pushed when she realized it was a stupid question, "Because we can leave if you really want?"

"I'm fine." Sam lied, before admitting, "It will just take some getting used too, is all."

"I'm sure." Alex nodded, placing her hand back over Sam's, "And I'm sure you can do this."

"Thanks." Sam smiled softly, enjoying the feeling of Alex's hand on hers, before requesting, "It might help if somebody distracted me."

"Oh?" Alex smirked wickedly, "And what did you have in mind?"

"Nothing like that." Sam blushed, before stammering, "I just, I... I..."

"I didn't say anything." Alex pointed out, trying not to sound smug, as she added, "If you took that as dirty, that's on you."

"Oh come on, it was so totally implied." Sam huffed, before admitting, "That kind of worked."

"You're welcome." Alex smiled.

"Say something else?" Sam pleaded.

"Something else." Alex replied childishly, before questioning, "Like what?"

"I don't know..." Sam grumbled, "Anything?"

Alex raised an eyebrow in response, which may have come across as mocking, which was unintentional. Luckily it was quickly forgotten as they proceeded to talk about anything and everything over the next few hours as things kind of returned to normal between them. More or less. The beginning there was kind of awkward, but they gradually grew more comfortable with each other, which helped with Alex's nerves. She was still second guessing her decision to bring Sam here, especially as whenever there was a pause in the conversation someone glanced around and look nervous. Although to be fair, that could be because Sam was on what she called her first date like ever.

It was actually kind of a rush for Alex to be treating Sam to her first proper date, even if it wasn't much. Admittedly it put more pressure on her, and Sam, but it was also kind of sweet, in a weird way. And once they actually settled into the date conversation flowed easily, and Alex's fear that she had ruined things were pretty much put to rest, as the other woman was constantly flirting with her. Mostly with little touches and looks, although there were a few light-hearted comments with some real meaning behind them. But just as Alex was regaining her stride, she had to go ruin it. Although, technically it wasn't her fault. No, it was the TV's fault for showing a certain superhero, and a certain superhero for showing up on the TV just behind Sam.

Turning to see what the fuss was about Sam then smiled wickedly, and teased, "Oh look, it's your girlfriend."

"She's not..." Alex began to protest, before cutting herself off in favour of the more appropriate response, "I'm just glad to see she has the situation under control."

"Uh-huh." Sam hummed dismissively.

"If not for her, that would have to be me out there, sorting out that mess." Alex argued.

"Uh-huh." Sam hummed dismissively.

"Then I might have to leave, and that would be a tragedy." Alex pointed out.

"That would be." Sam admitted softly, before adding with a chuckle, "Besides, you wouldn't want to get in the middle of her and Lena, would you?"

"There's something going on with Supergirl and Lena?" Alex frowned, "Does Kara know?"

For a few long seconds. Sam just stared at her date in confusion, and then realization hit, "Oh... I forgot."

"Forgot what?" Alex questioned.

"Nothing." Sam said unconvincingly, before distracting the other woman by pointing out, "You know, now I think about it, getting in the middle could be kind of fun."

"What?" Alex frowned, thoroughly confused.

"You know, like literally in the middle." Sam leaned in and whispered just about loud enough for Alex to hear it, "Lena Luthor on one side, Supergirl on the other... or maybe Kara? Or both? Think of all the fun you could have? Or, we could have? I mean, that's probably not a first date activity, but sometime in the future? Who knows?"

"Ewww!" Alex protested, before reminding her date, "Kara's my sister!"

"Foster sister." Sam countered, "You're not blood related, and you guys act more like best friends than sisters."

"Splitting hairs, and again, ewww." Alex protested.

"Maybe you'll change your mind someday." Sam hummed.

"Doubt it." Alex grumbled, before leaning in with a wicked smile, "But you, me and Supergirl? Now you're talking. Especially if you dress up in that cute little costume you were wearing the other night. Mmmmmmm, then I can have two Supergirls all to myself. Well, I guess Lena can come too, but she'd have to suit up. Oh yes, then I'd have Super Lena, Super Sam and Supergirl Classic. Oh God, that would be really something."

"It would." Sam agreed softly, before chuckling, "Oh my God, I never even thought about being with one woman until I met you, and now here we are discussing an all girl-foursome, featuring aliens, a billionaire and a secret agent. God, what have you done to me Alex Danvers?"

"Made your life a hell of a lot better." Alex said smugly, going for a laugh with that one, although she kind of meant it.

"You really have." Sam smiled softly, taking Alex's hand in hers again.

There was a brief pause as the two women just stared at each other, and then Alex said, almost casually, "Of course, that's not the real question you should be asking."

"No?" Sam raised an eyebrow, playing along, "And what is?"

Leaning in Alex whispered just loud enough for Sam to hear, "What I'm going to do to you tonight."

Sam blushed.


Over the next few hours Alex made it her mission to make the other woman blush as much as possible, without pushing things too far, of course, because Samantha Arias was truly breath-taking when she blushed. Well, Sam always was breath-taking, but somehow even more so when she blushed, and it was so intoxicating Alex worried she said the wrong thing more than once, only for Sam to put her at ease with an equally filthy comment. Which wasn't helped by the fact that they probably had too much to drink in the process. Or maybe that was keeping her from truly offending her date? Whatever the case, by the time they left the bar, Sam certainly wasn't thinking about her alien drama. Not from the way she was all over Alex.

The only downside to that moment was neither one of them was in a state where they could drive, but luckily there were ways around that. Namely, by calling them an Uber, and as they hadn't thought to call one before leaving the bar, that just gave them an excuse to spend the time making out, which was what they were only too happy to do, Alex pushing Sam back against the nearest wall while she invaded a very willing mouth with her tongue. As a result it only seemed to be a few seconds before the Uber arrived, which was actually disappointing. Because seriously, Alex could remember waiting forever for them previously, but when she actually wanted them to take their time, they were superefficient? WTF!

"Come on." Sam said, after she reluctantly broke the kiss, "The sooner we get back to your place, the sooner we can finish this."

"My place?" Alex questioned with a chuckle, before asking, even though she didn't want too, "What about Ruby?"

"Ruby told me that she would quote, kick my ass if I came home tonight." Sam giggled, still feeling very out of it, "She reminded me that she's old enough to be a babysitter, and doesn't want or need one. I mean, don't get me wrong, I made Kara promised to check up on her, but... I'm also kinda worried about scarring my kid. Because, you know..."

"She found me in your bed?" Alex offered solemnly.

"Yeah..." Sam said hesitantly, before reluctantly adding, "And... she hasn't said anything, but the way that she's been smirking at me makes me think that she heard something. And even if she didn't, if you keep fucking me like before, eventually she's going to hear something, and ewww. But... I, I really like you, and I don't want the night to end."

"Me neither." Alex admitted with a soft smile, gently stepping into Sam's personal space.

"So? Sam asked cautiously.

"So, let's get back to mine, and 'finish this'." Alex smirked.

"Yay!" Sam grinned, briefly giving Alex another kiss, before stumbling into the Uber.

Sam was kind of worried that she was coming across as too desperate, and they were moving too fast, and even if she wasn't putting Alex off at this point, she was definitely embarrassing herself. Because she wasn't this girl. She wasn't the girl who got drunk on a date, and abandoned her child just so that she could have sex. Especially not on a first date. Oh God, she was acting like a total slut. And to make matters worse, she didn't control herself in the car ride to Alex's apartment. No, she was able to control herself for about a couple of minutes, but then Alex took her hand and smiled at her, and the next thing Sam knew was that she was in the other woman's lap and kissing her fiercely.

That kiss pretty much lasted for the whole ride, and then through Alex paying the Uber, like the 'gentleman' she was. And they held hands and ran the entire way to the apartment, Sam kissing Alex again once they got to her front door. Which actually held them up a bit, but it was worth it to continue the kissing. Then they were making their way through the apartment, stripping off their clothes as they went, leaving a trail to the bedroom. Oh God, this was so hot. Something Sam had dreamed of for so long, but she never thought it would actually happen. That she could have a night like this. Which made her extremely grateful towards this amazing woman, and she wanted to reward her for it.

"What do you want?" Sam abruptly asked after breaking the latest kiss, and then quickly added just as abruptly, "Because whatever it is, we can do it. I want to do it. I, I'll do anything for you. Anything."

"Anything?" Alex smiled, before quipping, "Ever heard the saying, be careful what you wish for?"

"I mean it." Sam insisted, pressing her body firmly against the other woman's, and pushing, "There must be something you want? Like, like maybe I could go down on you? Or you could play with my ass some more? Seriously, what do you want. I, I... I just... you've made me feel things I've never imagined, and you've done so much, and this date, and I want it to be special, you know?"

"I get it." Alex said softly, biting her lip as she thought about it momentarily, before checking, "Are you sure?"

"Yes." Sam insisted, "I've never been more sure."

There was a brief pause, in which Alex bit her lip again, and then she ordered, "Get on your knees."

"Yes Ma'am." Sam gave a playful salute, and then quickly did as she was told.

Honestly Sam was kind of expecting to be made to eat pussy, or maybe even ass. She was still pretty nervous to do that, but she was currently filled with liquid courage, so this would probably be the best time to do it. But to her surprise Alex walked over to her chest of drawers, which was actually kind of a relief for Sam, as it meant that she wouldn't have to cross that line yet, and she was most likely about to get fucked by a sex toy. Which turned out to be very accurate, although the exact way was a wonderful surprise, as it meant the other woman would literally be fucking her like a man. Or at least, they could do things which Sam was somewhat more familiar with, because Alex pulled out a strap-on dildo, stepping into the harness and then pulling it up her thighs, so she could secure it around her waist.

"Oh my God..." Sam gasped, when the effect was complete, quickly adding when her words made Alex looked nervous, "You're so beautiful."

"Yeah?" Alex checked nervously.

"Oh yeah." Sam grinned, "Mmmmmmmmm, oh yeah, so hot. Can I suck it? Please? Can I?"

"That's the idea." Alex confessed with a wicked smile, before slowly closing the distance between them again.

Only too happy to oblige. Sam wrapped her lips around the head of that dildo as soon as it was in range and then started bobbing her head up and down the first few inches. She'd already done this a few times back in high school to keep her then boyfriend happy, not because she actually wanted too. So in a way, this was more enjoyable, because it was Alex. But Sam was also eager for it to be over, so they could get to the good stuff. Besides, she couldn't exactly take much of the cock into her mouth without gagging, given her lack of practice. Luckily Alex seemed content with Sam just concentrating on those first few inches for a few long minutes, then spitting onto the lower half and then rubbing it in with her hands. Which, as she was only too happy to point out, should be more than enough.

"There, that should be enough for my pussy?" Sam announced, already jumping onto her feet, but before she could go anywhere Alex said something which rooted her to the spot.

"And what makes you think I'm going to fuck your pussy? Or just your pussy?" Alex quipped, almost immediately regretting it when she saw the look on the other woman's face.

"You, you mean... what, what do you mean?" Sam asked, even though she had a good idea.

"Nothing." Alex quickly mumbled, lowering her head, and then when she sensed Sam giving her a look she continued, "It's just... you said anything, and..."

"And you really want to do, do that?" Sam blushed, however she didn't sound as disgusted or horrified as she maybe should do, which encouraged Alex to continue.

"Well..." Alex began hesitantly, before cautiously admitting, "I know what you must be thinking, because I thought all the same things. But that was before I tried it with Sara, and oh my God, it made me cum so hard. It hurt like hell, but it was so, so worth it. And you seemed to really like it when I, you know, licked you there. So, I thought if you tried it, you'd probably like it. And honestly, there are other things we can do, but I'm not sure you're ready for those. So, ironically, this seems like the best thing to me. Of course, we don't have too. And even if we do, I can fuck your pussy first. Pound you until you’re so delirious from pleasure you'll barely register the pain. Or I can spend the whole night in between your legs, trying to make up for this really, really bad idea."

There was a long pause, the longest of Alex's life, and then Sam took a deep, calming breath, and then slowly walked towards the bed while nervously encouraging, "If you're going to fuck my ass, fuck my ass. Quickly, before I change my mind."

Alex probably wouldn't have bought up this idea if she wasn't very drunk, and she knew just how much as she began explaining her reasoning, which ironically made her feel very sober. She was then drunk on something else when Samantha Arias crawled onto the bed and positioned herself in the centre of it with her cute little ass pointed directly at Alex. Oh God, Alex became drunk on her lust for this beautiful woman, and her perfect little booty, so much so she was reduced to doing this for a few long seconds. Then, just as she could sense Sam was opening her mouth to complain, Alex quickly got on the bed behind her lover, spread those well-rounded cheeks with both hands, stuck out her tongue, and continued the preparation.

She couldn't resist pressing her tongue to Sam's clit, and then sliding her tongue along the other woman's pussy, making them both cry out loudly in pleasure, even if Alex's cry was obviously muffled. Which was just a reminder that they could do something else if Sam got cold feet, mostly Alex just couldn't resist that pussy, and very nearly just kept licking it. But instead of just one, long, slow lick to Sam's twat Alex continued that long, slow lick all the way up the other girl's butt crack, her tongue inevitably sliding over her real target in the process. She then repeated the process over and over again, except ignoring the cunt in favour of the ass crack, but thankfully it continued to get very pleasant results. Namely her lover crying out, gasping, whimpering, and even moaning in pure pleasure.

Of course, all this was the easy part, given that Sam had already enjoyed a thorough rim job before. The real trick would be to see whether she could make her enjoy other forms of ass play, but if they were going to try that, it was only right to start off with a proven formula. So Alex continued licking that butt crack, gradually decreasing the range until she was just working on Sam's ass hole. Then she swirled around that cute little back door, instead of simply up and down, and even tried pushing her tongue inside it. Like before, she didn't get very far, but she got further than she thought she would be able to, definitely far enough to make a difference.

That rim job continued for a few long minutes after that, and then Alex replaced her tongue with a finger, briefly pausing to stick it into her mouth so it would be nice and wet. Both women then let out a soft cry of mostly pleasure as that finger was slowly pushed in up to the knuckle inside of Sam's ass. Alex then left it there for a few long seconds, allowing them to savour the sensation, and then pump that finger in and out, fucking Sam's ass with it. Oh yes, that hole was so tight. Which was incredibly exciting for Alex, but she worried it would mean that her friend couldn't take it. And worse, would force herself into a painful situation, just to try and please her.

Seemingly proving that point Sam moaned, "Alex, fuck me, mmmmmmmmm, fuck me please, before I lose my nerve."

"If you're not sure, maybe we shouldn't be doing this." Alex pointed out softly, "I knew it was a bad idea. I, I just got carried away, and-"

"I want to do it." Sam interrupted firmly, blushing slightly as she added, "I, I want to give you my ass on our first date."

"Really?" Alex questioned sceptically.

"Really." Sam confirmed, promising softly, "There is no one I'd rather take my ass cherry."

"Okay then..." Alex chuckled wickedly, unable to resist such an offer, before quickly adding, "But promise you'll tell me if it becomes too much."

"I promise." Sam quickly promised.

"And spread your cheeks." Alex added softly as she pulled her finger out of that forbidden hole, "Show me just how bad you want it."

"Yes Mistress." Sam said mockingly, although those words retroactively felt kind of serious as she did as she was told.

Sam felt the urge to tell Alex to stop almost immediately as she felt the head of that dildo being pressed against her ass hole. She must have tensed up or something because it stayed there for a few long moments. Or maybe Alex was savouring the moment? Whatever the case, it gave her a few precious seconds to relax, only for her to tense up again as her most private hole began stretching for an invading object which was much bigger than a finger. Which was really dumb of her, but she just couldn't help it. It was simply automatic. Even though it only caused her more pain. But the more she made that mistake, the more Sam was determined to do this, to the point that she was actually annoyed that Alex checked up on her.

"Sam?" Alex began cautiously.

"I'm fine, just do it." Sam Insisted.

There was a long pause, Alex clearly wanting to tell Sam to relax, and knowing that was obvious, and saying it would only insult Sam's intelligence. Thankfully her friend managed to avoid that urge, and instead slowly but surely caused Sam's ass hole to stretch wider, and wider, and wider until the head of the strap-on slid through her anal ring and into her bottom, making it official, Sam had just lost her back door cherry. She, she had lost her anal virginity. To a woman, no less. Oh God, she had lost it to Alex! Alex Danvers had just popped her anal cherry. On their first date! Oh God, this was so twisted on so many levels... and honestly, Sam kind of loved it. Far more than she ever thought she would.

Inevitably, there was pain, Sam unable to stop herself from crying out loudly, and then whimpering softly, but equally pathetically. But it more or less faded, thanks to Alex pausing while she relaxed, and the forementioned words to echo through her head as she focused on what exactly had just happened. Which was more or less the same thing when Alex slowly began pushing inch, after inch, after inch of strap-on cock into Sam's back hole and deep into her back passage. God, it felt like it would never end. And honestly, she kind of hoped it wouldn't. Well, she could have definitely done without the pain, but the mental stimulation was worth it, an Sam trusted that Alex had been telling the truth, and it would get better from here on out.

While Alex was being her usual perfect and considerate self throughout this, Sam kind of wished she wouldn't be. That she would point out what a giant slut Sam was being. How she had given her ass up on the first date. Fuck, she had even told that first date that they could do anything she wanted. God, that must've sounded so desperate. And now this first date, this woman, was taking something from her which she could never get back. One of her precious firsts, probably the last she had to give. And now, whenever she sat down, she was going to think about Alex Danvers. Oh God, just taunting herself with these thoughts was hot. Although to her delight, Alex seemed to be enjoying herself even more, given the way that when Sam finally looked back at her friend. Alex seemed fascinated by what was happening in front of her.

Alex wasn't just fascinated, she was consumed by the sight of inch after inch of her big dick sliding through Samantha Arias's most private hole and deep into the bowels of the former super villain. Of course it wasn't fair to consider Sam a former super villain, but in that moment it was hard not to think of the terrifying Reign, who had beaten the mighty Supergirl to a pulp, now bent over and spreading her cheeks so that Alex could get the best look possible of taking her ass cherry. But more importantly, this was her friend, Sam Arias, and Alex was desperately trying to listen out for signs that she couldn't take any more of this abuse, but she was worrying that she was missing it, because she was just so fascinated by the beautiful sight directly in front of her.

It was weird to think of it as beautiful, considering which hole was being taken, but Alex couldn't deny in that moment that was the way she felt. Oh yes, Samantha Arias had never looked more beautiful than when she was bent over and spreading her cheeks for a butt fucking. And her hole looked gorgeous stretching for that cock, allowing inch after inch of it inside her most private orifice. Alex's cock! Yes, it wasn't real, but the mental high that Alex was getting from this surely had to make this close enough. And it certainly felt that way when her thighs finally came to rest against those cute little ass cheeks, announcing every single inch of the dildo was buried deep within Sam Arias's butt.

There was a particularly long pause as Alex savoured the moment, and just the thought of it, for what felt like an eternity. Of course, just like the initial anal penetration, when she had officially taken Sam Arias's butt cherry, Alex also paused to allow her friend to relax, and allow the other woman to get used to it. Which was the least she could do, after Sara had done the same for her. God, Sara! She had an amazing ass, and Alex would forever regret not returning the favour, and getting a piece of it. Hell, she wanted the whole damn thing. Just like she had the whole of Samantha Arias in that moment. Oh yes, her dear friend Sam had been nice enough to give herself completely to Alex, and in a way she'd never given herself before, and it was up to Alex to make it worth it.

Desperately wanting to do that Alex took a calming breath, and as slowly as she possibly could began pulling her cock out of Sam's butt hole, and then when she was about half way out pushing all the way back in. She then repeated the process over and over again, officially starting to butt fuck another woman, for the first time in her life. To butt fuck Sam. Oh God, Alex was butt fucking Sam Arias! Fucking her in the butt, fucking her butt, butt fucking her, those words echoing in Alex's poor little mind as she again became fascinated by her strap-on, this time watching it sliding in and out of the other woman's most private hole, initially being unaware of what kind of reaction that was causing, except when it became deafening.

Sam had hoped this would be bearable, maybe even to the point were they could do this again. For Alex's benefit, of course, not her own. No, she wasn't one of those girls. An up the butt girl. Or at least, she hadn't thought she was, but maybe she should know better than to tempt fate, as Alex Danvers had a habit of turning her world upside down, and introducing her to pleasure she never knew she could enjoy. Or just never knew about at all. Ass play was the main one, the rim job, anal fingering and even the initial butt stuffing, making Sam hopeful that maybe, just maybe if Alex fingered her pussy and said the right words she would be able to cum from this, a massive step up to what she thought she would get, and a huge push into them doing this again.

However, apparently she had underestimated Alex's skills as a butt fucker, or her own body's responsiveness to anal sex. Probably both, as not only was the initial rectum stuffing a lot more bearable than Sam thought it would be, but when the sodomy officially got underway the pain faded away embarrassingly quickly, and worse was replaced by a growing sensation of pleasure. Which of course made Sam blush fiercely. Oh God, she was one of those girls. She was an up the butt girl! Oh God, Sam was so embarrassed. She tried to hide it, but she couldn't, and after only a few minutes of gentle ass fucking Sam actually found herself moaning in pleasure. More accurately, she had been stifling whimpers and cries before this, but this was a loud, unmistakable moan of pleasure, and it got Sam to blush fiercely again.

Especially as this caused Alex to grin, and softly whisper, "You're enjoying this, huh?"

"Apparently." Sam blushed.

"Good." Alex said softly, before admitting, "Because I want you to like everything we do together."

"I do." Sam replied without hesitation, and then blushed, "Apparently."

Which caused Alex to chuckle, "Well then, let's see just how much we can make you enjoy this."

In turn, that caused Sam to quip softly, "Is that a threat, or a promise?"

"Yes." Alex cheeked with a wicked grin.

Which caused Sam to roll her eyes, and she opened her mouth to give another response, only for it to become lost in a loud cry of pleasure as Alex gently increased the pace. It wasn't even that much at first, but it was enough to leave Sam an incoherent wreck. Alex then lent down so that her breasts, and her rock hard nipples, were pressing into her back, while she reached around to use her hands to attack Sam's tits. For a few long seconds those hands gently caressed her tits, before one slid downwards to replace Sam's hand, and all she had to do was gently start rubbing her there, combined with the breast play and constant anal pumping, pushed her painfully close towards orgasm.

"Cum for me Sam, cum for me!" Alex softly pleaded directly into Sam's ear, nibbling on it a little in between soft encouragement, commands and even some taunting, "Ohhhhhhhh yesssssssss, that's it, mmmmmmmm, I love it when you cum for me. Mmmmmmmm, and I love your ass. Oh yeah, I love fucking it, mmmmmmmm, and making you cum from it. Ooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhh, from cumming like a little anal slut, with my big dick in your tight little ass. Yesssssssss, cum like a nasty little up the butt girl. My up the butt girl. Oooooooooohhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssss, oh fuck, be my nasty little up the butt girl, who cums all over my fingers! Oooooooooohhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeeesssssssssss, cum for me Sam, OOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHH YEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSS, CUM FOR ME, YOU BEAUTIFUL LITTLE UP THE BUTT SLUT! AAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH FUCKKKKKKKKKKKKKK YEAHHHHHHHHHHH, MMMMMMMMMM FUCK!"

Those words combined with a slightly harder ass fucking made sure that Sam was on the edge of orgasm by the time two fingers were shoved into her needy little cunt. The additional penetration, send her crashing over the edge of a monster orgasm, which was somehow even more powerful than all the others Alex had given her. Or at least was equal to getting her pussy tongue fucked, again when she was on the edge of orgasm. And just like that experience she was allowed to cum over and over again, bringing Sam to the realization that while she might be an up the butt girl, that would be all right if she could be Alex Danvers's up the butt girl. Which was the last coherent thought she had for quite a while, before she became truly lost in the ecstasy she was receiving.

Alex definitely wanted Sam to be her up the butt girl. Oh yes, she wanted Sam Arias to be her anal loving slut, who couldn't get enough of it up the butt. Her cute little butt, which in that moment seemed to be made for fucking. Alex could definitely never get enough of fucking it. Of the feeling of Sam's well toned ass cheeks jiggling against her thighs with the force of each thrust, and the sound to echo throughout the room, along with her up the butt girl's whimpers and cries of ecstasy as she made her cum over and over again. And of course, the sheer joy of doing this to another woman. Of doing this to Samantha Arias. Her friend. Her lover. Her up the butt girl. God, this was so amazing.

Like before, Alex maybe got a little carried away with her encouragement, but Sam seemed too far gone to be offended by it. Or maybe even too far gone to register it. Although it must've been registering on some level, as it seemed to be having enough positive effect, and really, in that moment, that was all that mattered. Although, that wasn't just having positive reaction on Sam. No, for better or for worse, the other end of the dildo was bashing against her clit, which combined with her in words, and the sheer joy of fucking another woman in the ass actually made Alex cum. And it wasn't as hard and frequently as Sam cummimg was right now, or Alex had when she was on the receiving end, but it was maybe the most weirdly satisfying experience of her life.

Confident that Sam had been thoroughly loosened up thanks to her orgasms, and probably too far gone to notice the difference, Alex lifted herself up, grabbed a firm hold of her friend's waist, and then started using every ounce of strength she had left to brutalize Sam's butt hole. Given the high pitch whimper her friend let out as she lifted herself upwards Alex briefly wondered if she was making a mistake, but the way she made the other woman continue cumming for her made her confident that she had made the right decision. Either way it felt like this was the only way she could continue. And maybe even she couldn't help it, that she was giving into something primal.

For better or for worse, that allowed her to keep going for quite a while, powering herself through orgasm after orgasm in the process. Of course her stamina was not unlimited, which was probably a good thing, as there was only so much abuse Sam's poor little ass hole could take. And they certainly seemed to be past what Sam could take, as she collapsed face down, whimpering into the bed sheets. Feeling really guilty about that Alex quickly removed the dildo from the other woman's back door, and then from her own body, before cautiously reaching for her friend. Thankfully Sam embraced her without hesitation, even burying her head into Alex's chest, and then snuggling into her.

Alex allowed them a few long seconds to enjoy the moment, and then she softly asked, "Are you okay?"

"I'm so much better than okay." Sam moaned, snuggling more into her lover.

"Yeah?" Alex grinned, feeling proud of herself.

"Yeah." Sam confirmed, taking a deep breath before looking up and asking, "So, what are we going to do for a second date?"

This initially caused Alex to laugh, but just in case Sam misinterpreted that she told her, "Anything you want."

"Yeah?" Sam grinned softly.

"Yeah." Alex grinned back.

"Super." Sam teased, before snuggling back into her lover for a rest, before they had more fun.

Review Super Sam
Report Story