Adult-FanFiction.org : Comics

Super Awkward	By : MTL Category: DC Verse Television > SuperGirl Views: 5347 -:- Recommendations : 0 -:- Currently Reading : 0
Disclaimer: I do not own Supergirl or anything to do with DC. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

Chapter List
- 1
- 2
- 3
"Just one thing?" Sam asked softly as Alex was unlocking the door to her apartment, "Don't hate me?"
Alex Danvers was about to ask why her girlfriend Sam Arias thought she could ever hate her, then she got a pretty good reason when she opened the door to reveal Supergirl waiting for her. The same girl Alex had unwittingly confessed feelings for a short time ago, which would be bad enough, but then it was revealed that this was her sister. Meaning that obviously the last person she wanted to talk to right now was Kara Danvers. And having her dressed in that suit was just making it worse. But Alex couldn't seem to move. No, she was rooted to the spot, partly because of Sam's betrayal, but mostly because Kara was standing right in front of her, with an understandably worried look on her face.
"Hi Alex..." Kara greeted softly, then quickly pleaded when she saw her foster sister was about to bolt, "No, don't go. Please? We need to talk. You can't avoid me forever, you know?"
Despite wanting to argue otherwise Alex admitted after a long pause, "I know."
"Great." Kara beamed, before suggesting, "Do you wanna sit down and have a drink first?"
"God yes." Alex sighed and made her way over to the sofa, and a glass of wine, while adding without thinking about it, "And could you take that off?"
Unable to resist grinning bashfully Kara questioned, "Really?"
"You know what I mean!" Alex protested with a blush.
“Yeah, I guess.” Kara grinned.
Alex then downed the glass which was waiting for her, poured herself another, and then glared at a smug looking Lena Luthor, and questioned, "Does everybody really have to be here for this?"
"No." Sam replied quickly, firmly telling her, "We can leave if you want. Just say the word, and we'll do it. I swear."
"But you might want us to stay, at least for a while. Just to, clarify some things." Lena said cryptically.
"I want them here, to help me to talk you into staying, if necessary." Kara said softly, before protesting, "I wish it wasn't necessary, but you kind of left me no choice here. You won't return any of my messages, and you completely shut me down when I try, to talk to you at work. What am I supposed to do? We can't go on like this, you know? And I don't want too. You're my best friend Alex. I love you."
"I love you too Kara." Alex said automatically, before protesting, "I just need time."
"It's been weeks." Kara pointed out, "How much more time do you need?"
"I don't know." Alex grumbled, taking a big sip of her glass of wine.
There was a brief pause, then Kara pointed out, "It's affecting our work performance, you know?"
"Yeah, I know." Alex grumbled.
"Well, isn't that something you'd want to fix?" Kara questioned hopefully.
"Of course I want to fix it. I just can't do that over night." Alex whined, finishing her second glass and pouring another while adding, without looking at her sister, "It's... it's just going to take a minute to get over you. Supergirl! To get Supergirl out of my head. Because you're not... I'm not... you know what I mean!"
"Not really..." Kara grumbled, before admitting softly, "And that's kind of the problem."
"I know." Alex said softly.
"No, you don't..." Kara grumbled, before blurting out, "The problem is, I don't want you to get me out of your head."
"What?" Alex frowned.
"You heard me." Kara said boldly, deciding it was now or never, "I, I don't want you to get me out of your head, because I feel the same way. I have a crush on you too, Alex. I, I always have. In fact, I dismissed it as a girl crush for so long, when I know it's more. And as for you, too. So, why not explore it? See where it leads? Who knows, maybe we get it out of our system? Save ourselves from making a mistake at some point down the road, or not do anything about it, which I think would be the real tragedy. Or we could go on as we are, awkwardly repressing our feelings, even if it kills us a little more each day. Which I don't want. I, I want to show you just how much I love you."
There was another long pause, and then Alex turned to Sam, "Did you know about this?"
"Anyone with eyes knows about this." Lena grumbled.
"No one was talking to you." Alex snapped, "It's-"
"What, none of my business that my girlfriend is propositioning you?" Lena interrupted dryly.
"Alex!" Sam said firmly, hoping to give her girlfriend what she needed, "No one here is judging you. Me and Lena are here to see you and we support this idea, and we think it's what you really want. And maybe even what you need. If We're wrong, I'm sorry, but please just take a deep breath, and think for a second, okay? I know you're mad, but why? Because society thinks this is wrong? Your foster sisters, not sisters. You both attended a wedding between foster siblings, for God sakes. How is this different? God, I had feelings for women for years, but I didn't act on it, because it was frowned on by society. If there's any lesson from that, it should be don't listen to society. At least when it comes to sex."
Yet another long pause, and then Alex downed her latest glass of wine, pouring another one, and then repeating the process, before asking Sam, "You really don't mind?"
"I really don't." Sam promised, "I want this."
"We all do." Lena chimed in.
"Please Alex?" Kara pleaded, before beginning to babble nervously as Alex again downed her latest glass of wine, "We can make it a one time thing, if you want? And we can do whatever you want? Oh, and I can leave the suit on, if that helps? Whatever it takes. I just, I just want to find a way for you to be comfortable with this, because I really, really, really want this. I-"
The Girl of Steel was then cut off by Alex grabbing hold of her face and smashing their lips together. Something which she couldn't do unless Supergirl was willing, and in this case she was very, very willing, given how eagerly she kissed back. Which Alex wanted to be able to blame on the wine, and to be fair, she more or less had finished an entire bottle in just a few minutes, which was more than enough to get even inexperienced drinker like herself buzzed. However, if she was being honest with herself, she knew exactly what she was doing. She it was wrong, but she just didn't care. Hell, herself restrained had been hanging on by a thread, and when she had Kara, Lena, and maybe especially Sam pushing her into this poor Alex just couldn't take it anymore.
In the short time they had known each other Sam Arias had quickly become the voice of reason in Alex's chaotic life. Hell, lately she was pausing to question what Sam would do in any given situation, before allowing her temper to get the better of her. And now it was her girlfriend, pushing her into having sex with... Supergirl. Alex couldn't think of her as anything else right now. Not when her tongue was in her mouth, their bodies were pressed against each other, and one of her hands had even move down to squeeze Supergirl's butt. Something which continued for a few long minutes, before the kiss was broken and the two... co-workers took a few long seconds to catch their breath. Especially the one who initiated the kiss.
Then Alex turned to Sam and again questioned, "You really don't mind?"
"No." Sam reassured.
"As long as we get to watch." Lena purred, "And I get a turn with Sam."
"If that's okay with you." Sam quickly added, biting her lip, before continuing, "If not that's okay. Totally. It's just, well... I may have had a teeny tiny crush on my Boss, and while I would've never risked my job, and my friendship before... well, now it seems like a fair trade. But we don't have too. And we don't have to stay. Just say the word, and we'll leave. Both of us. I promise."
Yet another pause, this one brief, and then Alex said, "You can stay."
"You sure?" Sam pushed, as it was only fair.
"Yes." Alex said dismissively, turning her attention to... Supergirl, "You're Supergirl. No more, no less. Understand what I'm saying?"
"Yes Alex." Kara smiled.
"And that goes for you too." Alex shot a glare over at Lena, and then look back and forth between the two brunettes, "Both of you. In fact, the less you say the better. Ideally nothing."
"Yes Alex." Sam said softly, while Lena just made a motion of zipping her mouth closed.
"Right then, let's take this somewhere more private." Alex said, getting off the couch, and then pulling her shirt over her head while heading in the direction of the bedroom. She then quickly added, "Oh, and definitely leave the suit on."
"Yes Alex." Kara repeated with a grin, as she and the other girls followed her sibling into the bedroom.
Along the way Alex removed the rest of her clothing, while not looking behind her at the other women, then got onto the bed and then almost casually asked, "So Supergirl, you wanna fuck me, huh?"
"Erm, yes." Kara cleared her throat, and tried her best to put on her Supergirl persona.
"Really? Right here in front of your girlfriend? And mine? Huh?" Alex pushed, "Is Supergirl really that much of a slut?"
"Yes." Kara blushed, unable to argue, given the circumstances.
"Prove it." Alex further pushed, "Get over here and eat me. Mmmmmmmm yes, show me how much Supergirl loves pussy."
"Erm..." Kara hesitated, before questioning, "Foreplay, first?"
"Whatever." Alex said dismissively, "Make it quick."
"Yes Alex." Kara smiled.
Honestly, Alex didn't really need much foreplay, as her whole body was buzzing right now with excitement. She'd tried to fight these feelings ever since she re-learned who Supergirl was, along the way realizing that she had probably repressed some feelings for Kara. Along with every other girl in her teens. And now she was given permission by her girlfriend and... Supergirl too, to explore these feelings, how could she refuse? Even if it was weird having Lena and Sam taking a seat by the bed, in something that they had obviously set up earlier. Not that she had much time to think about that, as she was quickly straddled by the superhero, who gave her a deep and passionate kiss, which thankfully prevented her from thinking for a while.
Kara had definitely thought about this before. Like way, way too much, if she was honest with herself. Especially lately. Oh yes, Lena Luthor was giving her some of the best sex of her life, and yet, she just couldn't stop thinking about her older sister. And Alex didn't make it easy on her, being all sexy and perfect. And being an amazing kisser. Okay, she was only really finding out that now, but she had no doubt that Alex would be, because she was good at everything. So good, in fact, that the mighty Supergirl kind of forgot what she was doing there for a few long seconds. Also, there was the fact that Alex was naked, underneath her, and oh Rao, both of the siblings couldn't really think at that moment.
It didn't get much better when Kara broke the kiss, both in terms of the thinking thing, and the pleasure they were receiving. Oh yes, this was just as good, as Kara quickly moved her lips down to Alex's neck, and began covering it in kisses. Which made her want to mark that flesh, but it was more important than ever to ignore that feeling. Not because she might hurt the other girl, although that was still a concern. However, the most important thing to remember throughout this, was that Alex wasn't hers. No, she was Sam's, and despite what she was doing right now, Supergirl didn't want to come between them. Especially not with Sam sitting only a few feet away. With Lena, for that matter.
So instead, Kara took a few long minutes kissing up and down Alex's neck, before moving down to the other girl's tits. Which she did by slowly kissing her way down the soft flesh. And then kissing up it, round it, and side to side. Oh yes, Kara slid her lips all over those perky little titties, initially without taking a nipple into her mouth. Of course, it wasn't long before she began to gently take them into her mouth, both licking and sucking them. Especially as it had the exact reaction she'd been expecting from that. Namely gasps, cries, whimpers and moans. Which definitely caused her to get lost in that for a while, which was apparently too long for usually the more patient of the two siblings.
"Lower, mmmmmmm, please, go lower." Alex moaned, "You were the one who wanted to do this so bad that you seduced me, mmmmmmmm, you might as well go ahead and give me what I want. Oh yes, oooooooooooh fuckkkkkkkkkkk, oh God, Supergirl wants me so bad? Then do it! Fuck me! Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhh, fucking eat my pussy, you little bitch! Oooooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, show me how much Supergirl loves pussy! Fucking show me, ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh fuck yes! That's it Kara, I mean Supergirl. Get that pretty little mouth lower! Please? Oh please, oooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssss, fucking lick me!"
Hearing her big sister beg for her already was incredibly thrilling. Especially considering exactly what she was begging for. Which was kind of counterproductive for her, because it just made Kara want to listen to her all night long. Of course, she would never be that cruel. Also, her sister was asking for something. They both really, really wanted. So inevitably she did as she was told, and started moving her lips downwards towards the tasty treat which was waiting for her in between Alex's legs. Oh Rao, even without her heightened senses, the smell would've probably made her mouth water, but as it was, it was impressive that Kara didn't rush her movements, and made sure to cover her sibling's stomach in kisses as she got closer and closer to her destination.
Alex was getting really annoyed at the Super. She thought this was supposed to be a quick fuck, to get it out of her system, but the blonde was milking this for every second it was worth. Admittedly, there was part of her which was grateful for that, as she enjoyed foreplay as much as the next girl. However, there was a big difference between having Sam, Sara or Maggie slowly worshiping her body, and having... this girl do it. So she would really rather get to the good stuff, as soon as possible, before one of them chickened out. Probably her. Unfortunately Supergirl took her time teasing her, before finally pressing her tongue against the bottom of Alex's cunt, and slowly sliding it up to the top.
This of course, had her crying out loudly and joyfully, especially as Kara was thoughtful enough to linger her tongue against her clit for a few long seconds. For better or for worse that last part wasn't repeated, although it felt impossible to complain about that, considering she was still getting the wonderful sensation of another girl licking her pussy. God, how could Alex ever have mistaken herself for straight, when this was what was waiting for her, if she was just honest with herself? Fuck, she would be forever grateful to Maggie for setting her straight, so to speak. And of course, to Sara and Sam for reinforcing what her first girlfriend had so skilfully taught her.
With thoughts of her current girlfriend echoing through her head, Alex turned her head and refocused on her audience. For a few horrible seconds she worried that Sam would be angry and/or jealous, something she had every right to be, given the circumstances. Sure, Sam had pushed her into this, but there was a difference between imagining something, and actually doing it. Thankfully her girlfriend didn't seem upset by what she saw. In fact, she seemed very much into it. Although maybe not as much as Lena. Big surprise there, a Luthor was into some weird shit. But it was better than the alternative, namely the sister to a super villain with incredible resources being upset with her.
Both the watching brunettes were pretty much focused on the girl in between Alex's legs, and understandably so. Hell, it wasn't long before Alex's attention to return to her, and pretty much stayed there throughout the next few long minutes. However, there was a weirdly sweet moment where her eyes locked with Sam's, and the two girlfriends exchanged a soft smile. Wow, Alex couldn't believe she had a girlfriend, who not only encouraged her to do this, but wanted to see her actually do it. Although she wondered whether she would be able to be so cool with the idea of Lena fucking her girl. It was kind of hard to imagine, but then again, she couldn't have imagined that she'd be spreading her legs one day, so that her foster sister could eat her fucking cunt.
Kara was a little nervous about their audience, but she completely forgot about them the second she tasted pussy. Which was hardly surprising, given this was her sister's pussy. Yes, they weren't blood related, but Eliza Danvers had tried to drill the idea into their heads ever since the Kryptonian had arrived on Earth. Which should have been off-putting, but for Kara, it just added a twisted to thrill to this moment. One that she very much enjoyed throughout the night, although maybe especially when her head was in between her big sister's legs, and her whole world was Alex Danvers. Something which was heaven as far as Supergirl was concerned, especially given the yummy flavour.
Ever since she had first gone down on her precious Lena, Kara knew she loved the taste of pussy, and having a connection with the woman in question made everything so much more intense. So, unsurprisingly, she found that Lena Luthor and Alex Danvers were absolutely delicious. Who was better? It was impossible to tell, given they were both so very yummy. And maybe it would be the same for other women, but Kara doubted it, because what could taste better than this? Other than the girl cum of these women, of course, and given how much she loved her girlfriend's cum, she was sure her sister's cum would be amazing. But for now, she was very much enjoying savouring this wonderful flavour, and moment.
Which meant of course, long, slow licks, starting from the bottom of her older sister's pussy and working her way right up to the top, where she mostly avoided Alex's clit. Of course, Kara couldn't resist ignoring entirely. Not when she knew what wonderful sounds that could cause. And sure enough, her big sister cried out extra loudly whenever she then brushed her tongue against her clit. Oh Rao, that was so very satisfying. Especially as it made Lena chuckle with delight as well. Lena, Kara thought with a smile. The woman responsible for pushing her into this. For allowing her to indulge in her naughtiest desires, and was even providing encouragement now. Sometimes, when Alex couldn't.
"More! More, more, mmmmmmmmmm, more! Ah fuck!" Alex moaned joyfully, "Lick my clit, ah shit! Oh Kara! Kara, oooooooooooh, Supergirl! Tongue my clit Supergirl, show me what a Super Pussy Licker you are! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssssss, just like that, just like that, ooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhh, that's it, ah fuck!"
"Yes, that is it, Kara!" Lena grinned, "Eat Alex's yummy little pussy just like that. Mmmmmmmmmm yes, good girl. Good little cunt loving slut. You make me so proud. Ooooooooooh, show your sister how much you love her. And us! Yessssssssss, oh yes, put on a show. Oh yeah, this is way better than dinner and a movie."
"I've definitely had worse dates." Sam quipped dryly.
"Me too." Lena chuckled.
Only too happy to oblige, Kara started touching her sibling's clit with every other lick, then almost every lick, followed by every single one of them. Oh yes, Kara tried to build up to it, just like Lena had taught her, but it was so hard when all she wanted to do was attacked the sensitive bundle of nerves and make her precious big sister cum for her. Ironically, at the same time, all she wanted to do was savour this moment. Which was a weird paradox, but a very enjoyable one. Especially because it caused Alex to make some truly wonderful sounds. Namely whimpers, gasps, moans and cries of pure pleasure. Which only became more wonderful as time went on. And then of course, inevitably, she got the permission she had been waiting for.
Alex was also trapped in a weird paradox, where she wanted this to last forever, and at the same time she just really wanted to cum. Which to be fair, was a paradox she was very familiar with, especially when there was another woman in between her legs. Oh yes, Maggie, Sara, Sam and now Kara... Supergirl had done, and was doing, a great job with providing her incredible pleasure, which made her want this moment to last, and receive the ecstasy that would come after it as soon as possible. It was a tough choice, but as always she found herself holding back for as long as she could, if nothing else, to save her reputation as a bad ass, which felt like it would be in jeopardy if she begged too soon.
For better or worse, this may be her toughest challenge ever, it was incredibly hard to take her mind off what was happening to her. Especially given the audience they had. Oh God, she could not only not look down, but now she just had to look straight ahead, or to just one side, entirely aware on the other side was her watching girlfriend, and her sister's girlfriend. Two women who she had grown very close too, and deeply respected, watching her little sister eat her pussy. Watching her precious Kara, the girl she was supposed to protect, tongue her twat. Oh fuck, she was committing incest with the most important member of her family, ruining her most important relationship in the process.
It was something that she was no longer able to ignore, which filled Alex with incredible shame. Especially because it didn't put her off. No, if anything, it only pushed her closer to orgasm. Oh God, part of her was surprised she didn't just cum on the spot, and part of her even tried to avoid having to go through the humiliation of having to ask her little sister to make her cum. First, by looking over at her audience, and thankfully still finding encouraging looks, and then another by looking down in between her legs to see a pretty blonde head and feminine body glued to her crotch. And reminding herself, over and over again and again, it was her sister. But it was no use, as clearly Kara had been too well-trained. Trained by Lena Luthor to decreased the force of her licks, to keep someone on the edge. Meaning there was only one thing left to do.
"Make me cum, oh God, please make me cum!" Alex whimpered softly, then got increasingly loud as the need became overwhelming, "Fuck me! Oh please, mmmmmmmmm, fuck me! Ooooooooooh yesssssssssss, lick my clit more! Yessssssssssssssss, oh fuck, fuck me Supergirl! Please, tongue fuck me! Tongue fuck me... Kara! Oh Kara, oh please, mmmmmmmmm, I want it! I need it! Oh please, please give it to me! Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhhhhhh, good girl, ooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkk yeeeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, fuck me! FUCK ME! Oh God, make me cum make me cum make me cum AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDDDD!"
Thankfully she wasn't waiting long before receiving the incredible pleasure she felt like she physically needed in that moment. Namely from Kara focusing on her clit, first with just a series of licks, and then by taking it into her mouth and sucking on it, in between more licks. Which was more than enough to make her in coherent, and at least for a few long seconds, it was enough additional pleasure to satisfy her. Then when it started feeling more like teasing her, like her previous lovers, Kara gave her what she wanted right away. Oh God, the mighty Supergirl/her own sister, shoved her tongue deep inside her, triggering a powerful climax, which was quickly followed by another and another and another.
Kara was never more grateful for her superspeed then in moments like this, as it allowed her to pull her tongue out of Alex's cunt, wrapped her lips around that entrance, and swallow everything her big sister had to give her. Oh yes, she was able to get every drop of that first orgasm, and she could've easily got the rest, if she wanted too. However, there was definitely something to be said for allowing some to escape out onto her face, marking her as what she was, a pussy loving little slut. Which had never been more true, given that she was fucking her own sister, in front of their girlfriends. Oh Rao, this was so twisted, and Kara loved every single second of it.
She probably should be checking that Sam and especially Lena were still cool with this, but pretty much ever since her tongue had touched Alex's pussy, she became lost in this perverted act, and that was definitely true throughout, making her big sister cum for her. Something she did over and over again. Which was pretty easy now that Alex had been worked up, although the skills that she learned from fucking Lena Luthor was also a factor, she was proud to say. Admittedly, there was also her superspeed, which she definitely used to her advantage. And not just when it came to switching between tongue fucking and swallowing cum. No, she also used a little bit of the superspeed during the tongue fucking, which unsurprisingly, had very positive results.
It was the same story when she added her fingers into the mix, pushing one, and then two into Alex's pussy and fucking her with them as quick and hard as she dared. Which sadly meant she could no longer taste her sibling in the same way, but she got to suck on her clit, and that was definitely something. She also got to look up into Alex's beautiful face, and see just how much she was pleasing her. Oh Rao, the look on her face made Kara's heart flutter. but sadly, it was also course concern. After all, as much as she wanted to fuck her sister into unconsciousness, selfishly she wanted her to return the favour. And she knew exactly how she wanted her to do it.
So while it pained her, she bought Alex down from her high, and then crawled her way up her body, so she could gently stroked her pretty face until she was ready for more. Also kissing. Lots and lots of kissing. Oh yes, Kara could barely wait a full minute for Alex to catch her breath, before she was kissing her sister again, this time feeding her the yummy taste of her own cum and pussy cream. Something which always seemed to reinvigorate Lena, and thankfully Alex was the same way. Oh yes, her sister kissed back with increasing passion, at one point even moving so that she was on top. Which Kara could've easily stopped, but why would she want to do a thing like that?
"I wanna fuck you." Alex gasped, when she finally broke the kiss.
"Can it be up the butt?" Kara asked shamelessly, and then when her sister looked surprised she blushed and explained, "I, I've kind of had a thing for it ever since you talked about fucking Supergirl's quote 'perfect' ass. And since Lena took my anal cherry. And, and when I accidentally saw you sodomizing Sam, while she was wearing Supergirl's costume."
"You saw that?" Sam blushed.
"Accidentally?" Alex questioned dryly.
"Well... I was just checking up on you, and it just kind of, happened." Kara explained bashfully.
"Sounds like I should be spanking you, not rewarding you." Alex grumbled, before getting off of her sister, and ordering, "But, I guess I can do that while butt fucking you."
"Yay!" Kara grinned happily, opening her mouth to say more, before being interrupted.
"Bend over and shut up Supergirl." Alex ordered, "It's time for your cute little ass to get what it deserves."
"I assure you, it gets what it deserves on a regular basis." Lena quipped.
"What did I say about shutting up?" Alex grumbled, briefly glaring at Lena, who just shrugged at her.
Alex then turned her attention to Supergirl, as she slowly turned herself over onto all fours and lifted her ass into the air. Which she hadn't been ordered to do, but she was right on the money of where Alex wanted her, and she probably figured that she could change positions if need be. Oh God, she even reached back to pull her skirt up, and her underwear down, exposing her cute little butt hole. Also her very wet pussy, both of which were literally mouth-watering. It was literally true for the DEO Agent, who kept her eyes on her prize as she retrieved a nice big strap-on, attached it to herself, and then stroked some lubricant into it. Then she kneeled down behind her prey, and without warning, buried her face in between those cheeks.
Unsurprisingly, this had the mighty Supergirl gasping loudly, but that was quickly followed by a happy little moan as her own sister started tonguing her butt hole. Which was almost enough to give Alex pause, but at this point, she was too far gone. She just needed to fuck Kara so badly, and in the most twisted way possible. And there wasn't anything more twisted than what she was about to do, or she was currently doing. Especially when she spread those cheeks nice and wide, so that Lena and Sam could get the best look possible at Alex sliding her tongue up and down her little sister's ass hole over and over again, getting it nice and wet for her big strap-on cock.
For a while Alex became lost in that rim job, although no one complained. Maybe because she kept things entertaining, first by pulling back every so often to spit onto Kara's ass hole, and then rub it in with her tongue, then increasing the pace of the licking. She also started swirling her tongue all around that forbidden hole, and even tried to push it inside. Although, unsurprisingly she didn't get very far. Oh yes, just like her precious girlfriend, this back door was pretty much impossible to get open, proving that either Kara had been lying about losing her butt cherry, or far more likely, that Kryptonians were forever virgin tight back there. Oh God, this was a virgin tight ass, making Kara the perfect little anal fuck toy. Just like Sam.
Eventually Alex put that theory to the test, by pulling her tongue out of it, and after spitting on it one more time, pressed a finger, which was still wet with lube from preparing the toy, against Kara's back hole, and slowly pushed it into that forbidden orifice. Into Supergirl's shit hole! Her baby sister's butt hole! Some form of those words echoed in Alex's mind as she pushed that finger all the way inside that incredibly tight hole. So tight, that she thought that poor digit was going to be crushed for sure. Then she became hyperaware of the fact that both she and her sister were moaning with pure pleasure throughout this experience, something very promising. Which she just had to gloat about, as she began sliding that finger in and out of that tight little fuck hole.
"Wow, you really love that, huh?" Alex teased.
"Uh-huh." Kara moaned in agreement, "I love it up the butt."
"She's a total anal slut." Lena grinned, unable to resist telling Alex that, or asking her, "Is Sam the same way?"
"Lena!" Sam blushed and protest.
"Yes." Alex grinned wickedly back at the other top, "Must be a Kryptonian thing."
"Alex?" Sam whined, although it was less than half-hearted, as she was rather enjoying this embarrassing topic.
Sensing that Alex continued, "And no matter how hard or regularly I fuck it, Sam's ass is always virgin tight. Just like this perfect little hole. So maybe they really were made to be butt fucked?"
"Looks like." Lena agreed, returning her full attention to her blushing friend while adding, "I can't wait to find out if Sam is as natural an anal slut as my darling Kara!"
"Me too." Alex agreed, pulling out her finger and smacking her sister's ass to emphasize her next words, "Spread your cheeks, slut. Oh yeah, let's see just how much of an anal slut Supergirl really is."
Kara was only too happy to oblige, pressing her face to the bed sheets, reaching back, and spreading her butt cheeks as wide as she possibly could, offering up her most private hole to Alex for their mutual pleasure. Offering it up to her foster sister. They weren't related by blood, and Kara had always seen them as best friends more than sisters, but in that moment it was hard to forget about how they had been raised. Unfortunately, it seemed Alex was struggling not to think of that, given that she seemed to freeze. Thankfully, as it turned out her 'big sister' was just enjoying the view, before pressing the strap-on firmly against Supergirl's ass hole and slowly started causing it to stretch open.
The anal penetration was as slow as it could possibly be, which Kara liked to believe was a result of Alex trying to allow them both to savour the moment, given that the other girl knew perfectly well she'd been through a lot worse than this. As a result, Supergirl cried out in mostly pleasure when her butt hole stretched wide enough to allow the head of that big dildo to slide through it and into her slutty little ass. Something else she got to savour for a few long seconds, before Alex started pushing forwards slowly causing inch after inch of 'girl cock' to slide into her bottom. Which felt better than she ever imagined it would, before being introduced to the wonders of anal sex by Lena Luthor.
Even if she was anally penetrated and stuff by her second ever woman, and the second ever person, at that, Kara found her mind wandering to her girlfriend, and not just because she was in the room with her. No, Lena had been the one to take her anal cherry, so of course, she would always think of her when taking it up the butt. Or whenever she sat down. Or well, any number of things, it was kind of hard not to think about her. But especially now she was indulging in multiple fantasies at once. In fact, Kara felt so grateful to her girlfriend that she actually looked over at her, and smiled bashfully, in a small sign of gratitude. Lena then of course smiled back, albeit with a smile which was a lot more wicked. Hell, her woman looked like she wanted to say something, and it was only fear of scaring off Alex, and maybe Sam, that kept her quiet.
Admittedly, Alex and even Sam didn't seem like they were going to run off anytime soon. No, they seemed enthralled with the perverted show in front of them, the only difference being that Sam was just watching, while Alex was being a very active participant. Oh yes, Alex was doing a wonderful job at stuffing Kara's ass full of strap-on nice and slow, allowing everyone in the room to savour every sweet moment of it. Of course, inevitably she ran out of cock. Fuck yeah, the big sister's thighs came to rest against the little sister's butt cheeks, announcing every inch of that dildo was buried within Kara's bowels. Just the way she wanted. And something she was able to savour for a few long seconds, before the silence was broken. But not by Alex.
"See, I told you she was a good little anal slut." Lena said, unable to resist. Nor was she able to resist continuing, "Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhh, Supergirl is a total anal slut! My little anal slut. Oooooooooh, but I'm happy to share with you, Alex. Ohhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssss, fuck that ass. Fuck that slutty little Super ass. Oh yes, Supergirl was so good for you. Oh yes, taking every single inch of your cock up her butt like a little ass whore. So reward her. Reward Kara... I mean, Supergirl, for being the perfect anal loving bitch by fucking her up the ass. Oh yes, that's it, mmmmmmmm, good girls. Put on a show for me and Sam. Oooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, put on a show for your girlfriends! Oh yes!"
Alex blushed at receiving such a twisted encouragement, even though a twisted part of her rather enjoyed it. The same part which really enjoyed watching Kara's butt hole stretching around her big dick, and the fact that she just completely stuffed Supergirl's rectum with her big dick. Stuffed her baby sister's butt full of her cock. Because try as she might, Alex couldn't forget about how they were raised in that moment. Although to her shame, instead of putting her off, it only added to her enjoyment. Just like before. In fact, all these things combined made her feel like she wanted to cum already. Or at the very least, do something else which should've been unthinkable. Namely, to officially start fucking her little sister in the ass.
It was the latter thing she started doing, partly because of Lena's encouragement, but mostly because she just couldn't resist. To be fair, at first it was like her body was on autopilot, thanks to what felt like non-stop anal sex with her beautiful girlfriend Sam Arias. Oh yes, Sam had a truly beautiful bottom which Alex just couldn't seem to get enough of fucking. It was like an addiction. Something she needed to do every day, and yet somehow, her girl remained virgin tight. Just like this equally wonderful booty, which Alex just couldn't resist sliding her dick in and out of, meaning that she was officially sodomizing Supergirl. And more importantly, officially sodomizing her little sister.
Which was something that Alex became completely lost in for what felt like an eternity. Especially because the other girl was continuing to spread her ass cheeks, meaning that the entire time she, and everyone else watching, got the perfect view of that big dick sliding in and out of the mighty Supergirl's most private hole. Also, there was the fact that this total anal slut was moaning, whimpering, and crying out in seemingly pure pleasure the entire time. Fuck, she had been making those sounds right from the beginning, proving just how much she loved getting butt fucked. Just like her beloved Sam. Oh God, were all Kryptonians shameless anal whores? Or just Kara and Sam?
Honestly, Alex didn't really care, so long as the two girls had that in common, as it made this whole thing so much easier. Hell, it helped that they were also the kind of pervs who enjoyed watching their girlfriend having sex, or just enjoyed putting on a show. Or at least, it certainly seemed that was the case, given this wicked plan they had agreed to, and Lena had probably come up with. The question was, would Alex be okay with watching Sam do this with someone else? With Lena? It seemed only fair that she at least give it a chance, but in that moment she was unsure, simply because she selfishly wanted these perfect little anal subs, and their perfect little asses, all to herself.
Kara worried about that too, although honestly, she was pretty sure that her lust would override whatever jealousy she may feel. She was kind of embarrassed about that, she was supposed to be Supergirl, a role model for girls everywhere could look up too. But it was true, so hopefully it would be okay, so long as no one found out about it. Rao knows, no one could find out about her getting fucked in the ass by her foster sister. Because it wouldn't matter they weren't related by blood, the scandal would still be astronomical. However, in this particular moment, the idea of such a thing actually turned Kara on. Which was also embarrassing, but she couldn't help it. Oh God, she really was a slut.
Given she wanted this to last as long as possible Kara tried not to think about that, or all of the wonderful combinations of herself, Alex, Sam and of course Lena that could be possible now. And all of the things they could do together. Like all three of the other women gang up on her, making her go back and forth in between their pussies and asses, or making her air tight. Oh yes, that was the exact kind of thing she had to avoid thinking about. And exactly who was fucking her in the butt right now. She shouldn't be thinking about any of that, but she just couldn't help it. Luckily for her, she could still find a way to hold back on begging to cum too soon. Even if it was kind of painful. On the other hand, even Supergirl had her limits, and eventually she just couldn't take it anymore.
"Harder! Fuck me harder, Alex! Oooooooooooh yesssssssssssss, fuck Supergirl's butt! Ah fuck!" Kara pleaded, trying to choose her words carefully, "Yessssssssss, butt fuck me! Butt fuck Supergirl! Ohhhhhhhhh Rao, fuck Supergirl in the butt! Oh yes, fuck that tight little ass hard and deep and make me cum! Oh please Alex, mmmmmmmmm, please make me cum! Ohhhhhhhhhhh, make me cum like the good little anal slut I am! Ooooooooooh, prove Lena Luthor right. Prove that Supergirl is a total anal whore! Your anal loving whore! Mmmmmmmm, your anal bitch! Oh yeah, oooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhhhh, make Supergirl your anal bitch! Make me oooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh Goooooooooooooooddddddddddddd yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssssss, OOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHH GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODDDDDDDDDDDDD YEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS!"
Thankfully Alex was quick to give her what she wanted, increasing the pace until she was using what had to be every ounce of her strength to fuck her slutty little ass hole! Alex! Her Alex! Oh Rao, her big sister Alex Danvers was using every ounce of her strength to sodomize her hard and rough, effortlessly sending the strong, powerful role model that was Supergirl over the edge of a powerful climax, without ever having to touch her pussy. In that moment it didn't matter that Alex wasn't her blood, Kara wanted to think of her as her sister, because it made the pleasure that much more wonderfully overwhelming. As did the fact that her sister's girlfriend, and her own, were witnessing this perverted display.
It was one which had the Kryptonian slamming her butt back against the admirable thrusts of the human, perhaps truly making this a rectum wrecking in the process. If not, then when she completely took over. It was definitely that. Oh yes, when she could sense that her lover was running out of steam, Kara flipped them over, and shamelessly anally rode Alex's strap-on in the reverse cowgirl position. As a result her cum, which was seemingly constantly squirting out of her cunt, pretty much flew across the room, and the mighty Supergirl brutalized her own bowels like she was literally trying to ruin them. Hell, it was probably only going to be her super healing, which made sure she was able to sit down again. After all, that's what happened the last few times she had been fucked up the ass.
Alex knew how Sam could get during a butt fucking, so she wasn't surprised when Kara started slamming back against her. She was however, surprised when Kara flipped the positions. Sam wasn't normally that bold. However, it was a welcome surprise, especially as Alex had a little energy left over, that she was able to use to pound upwards into that slutty little butt hole, and thus make this little butt slut cum that much harder and more frequently. Or at least, she liked to think so. Because sure, the mighty Supergirl could do all the work at this point, but hopefully she added a further thrill for the other girl. Especially given the relationship they had to each other.
Because again, while Alex had been trying to ignore it, at this moment it was hard to put out of her mind that this was her sister Kara Danvers. After all, she had thought of her that way for so long, and it was hard to unsee it, even when she was wearing that ridiculous costume. It was a little easier when Kara had been face down, as at least then Alex could concentrate on that perfect ass of hers. First, the way it would stretch around her strap-on, and then how the cheeks jiggled against her thighs once they reached the deep, hard anal pounding. Well, she couldn't feel it, but now she was mostly focused on the beautiful sight of Supergirl, bouncing up and down her dick, constantly catching a glimpse of that beautiful face of her, and wondered how she ever forgot this was her beloved sister.
Ironically, it was that love, and the fact that she was perverting it in a truly unspeakable way, which might just be the thing which pushed Alex over the edge of cumming. Of course, the constant bashing against her clit by the other end of the dildo, the feeling of flesh smacking off flesh, the sounds that the other woman was making, the fact that they were being watched, and the sheer joy of sodomizing Supergirl had a lot to do with it. But Alex was pretty sure the fact that this was her beloved sister Kara, who she loved very deeply, was the thing that did it. And whatever the case, she was able to push herself through it, and onto another, and another, and another, so they could all become lost in this wonderful ecstasy.
Maybe Alex more than Kara, given the fact that the next thing she knew they were lying in a sweaty heap, and Lena Luthor was leaning over them with a wicked smile on her face. Lena then leaned down to kiss Kara, while Alex's cock was still completely buried inside of Supergirl's butt. Cautiously Sam did the same thing, only she kissed Alex. Briefly at first, but it soon became a nice, long making out session. Again, while one sister's strap-on was buried in the other's ass. Which in a weird way, was a sign that their girlfriends approved of what they had just done. The real question was, what now? Because Alex had a few ideas, she just wasn't sure if she could go through with them.
- 1
- 2
- 3
You need to be logged in to leave a review for this story.
Report Story

Super Awkward